Olivia Colman and Claire Foy: Two Queens in The Crown

Few roles in British television carry as much weight as Queen Elizabeth II in The Crown, and fewer still have been shared by two actresses of the calibre of Claire Foy and Olivia Colman. Foy created the part, playing the young Queen as she learned to rule in the first two series. Colman then took the crown for series three and four, carrying the same woman through middle age. Between them, they turned one character into two distinct, award-winning performances, and the handover became one of the most talked-about casting decisions in modern television.

What makes the pairing so unusual is that neither actress was imitating the other. Foy built the Queen from youth, a 25-year-old suddenly on the throne. Colman inherited that foundation and had to make it older, wearier and harder, without losing the thread Foy had set down. The result was a rare achievement: a Golden Globe and a Primetime Emmy for Lead Actress won by two different women for playing the same person in the same series.

The handover The Crown planned from the start

The Crown was designed around recasting. Created by Peter Morgan and produced by Left Bank Pictures for Netflix, the series follows the reign of Queen Elizabeth II from her wedding in 1947 to the wedding of Prince Charles and Camilla Parker Bowles in 2005, spanning almost six decades. so the plan was to change the principal cast every two series as the characters aged: Foy as the young Queen, Colman in middle age, and Imelda Staunton in her later years.

The announcement that Colman would succeed Foy came in October 2017, before the second series had even aired. Colman was frank about the task, saying she planned to re-watch every episode and copy Foy, and calling her predecessor an incredibly hard act to follow. Foy was generous in return, saying she loved and admired Colman. Colman did not erase Foy’s Queen, she aged her.

Claire Foy: the young Queen who found her authority

Claire Elizabeth Foy was born on 16 April 1984 in Stockport, Greater Manchester. She studied drama at Liverpool John Moores University, trained at the Oxford School of Drama, and made her stage debut at the Royal National Theatre. Her first leading television role came quickly: she played Amy Dorrit in the BBC’s Little Dorrit in 2008, earning a Royal Television Society nomination.

The role that announced her as a serious dramatic actress came in 2015, when she played Anne Boleyn in the BBC’s Wolf Hall, opposite Mark Rylance and Damian Lewis. Her performance won widespread praise and a BAFTA nomination for Best Actress, and it showed exactly the qualities The Crown would need: stillness, intelligence and a woman holding herself together under pressure. A year later, she was the Queen herself.

Foy’s Elizabeth becomes Queen at 25 on the death of her father, George VI. The first series covers 1947 to 1955, taking in the accession and the coronation, while the second covers 1956 to 1964, including the Suez Crisis. Foy played her as a woman learning to separate feeling from duty, often saying very little. The performance won her the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Television Series Drama in 2017 and the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in 2018, along with two Screen Actors Guild Awards.

Olivia Colman: from comedy to the Crown

Olivia Colman was born Sarah Caroline Olivia Colman on 30 January 1974 in Norwich, Norfolk. She discovered acting at Gresham’s School in Holt and trained at the Bristol Old Vic Theatre School, graduating in 1999. Her breakthrough came in comedy: from 2003 she played Sophie Chapman in the Channel 4 sitcom Peep Show, alongside David Mitchell and Robert Webb, a role she held for twelve years.

The turn towards drama was steady, and it was decisive. In Broadchurch, which ran from 2013 to 2017, she played Detective Sergeant Ellie Miller opposite David Tennant, winning the BAFTA TV Award for Best Actress in 2014. In 2016 she won a Golden Globe for her supporting role in The Night Manager. Then came The Favourite in 2018, in which she played Queen Anne, an eccentric, sickly and lonely monarch, opposite Rachel Weisz and Emma Stone. The performance won her the Academy Award for Best Actress at the ceremony in February 2019.

Colman took over The Crown in the third series, released in November 2019, with the fourth following on 15 November 2020. Her Queen covers a different era: the 1960s and 1970s in series three, then the 1980s in series four, with Margaret Thatcher in Downing Street and Diana, Princess of Wales, entering the royal family. Where Foy’s Queen was learning the job, Colman’s already knew it, and the drama came from the cost of knowing it too well. She won the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Television Series Drama in 2020 and the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in 2021.

Two performances, one character

The most interesting thing about watching Foy and Colman back to back is how much they share and how much they differ. Both play the Queen as a woman who keeps her feelings private, using small details rather than big speeches. Foy’s Queen is more visibly uncertain, because she is younger and the crown is new; her authority grows episode by episode. Colman’s Queen has the authority already, and the tension comes from what it has cost her: a marriage settled into distance, and a country changing faster than the institution she represents.

Their backgrounds shaped the difference. Foy came to the role through classical drama and period pieces, and her Queen feels precise and contained. Colman came through comedy, and that training gave her Queen something unexpected: timing. Her Elizabeth can be dry, even funny, which makes the sadness land harder. British screen history is full of celebrated pairings of actresses who defined an era together, and Kate Winslet and Keira Knightley are often mentioned in the same breath, but Foy and Colman are rarer still, because they did not simply work alongside each other: they built one character between them.

The rare awards double

What sets Foy and Colman apart from almost every other shared role in television history is what happened at the awards ceremonies. Both won the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Television Series Drama for playing Elizabeth II, Foy in 2017 and Colman in 2020. Both won the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series for the same role, Foy in 2018 and Colman in 2021. Two actresses, one character, the same two trophies.

The symmetry goes further. Foy also won two Screen Actors Guild Awards for the role. Colman, meanwhile, holds something Foy does not: an Academy Award, won for The Favourite before she had even appeared in The Crown. Foy has never been Oscar-nominated, and her film career took a different path, including a Golden Globe-nominated supporting turn as Janet Armstrong in First Man. The comparison is not a contest. The Crown gave each of them the role of a lifetime, and each gave the role something the other could not.

The returns: Foy comes back, and three Queens share the screen

The story did not end when Colman took over. Foy returned in 2020, appearing as the young Queen in the eighth episode of the fourth series, in a flashback to the Queen’s younger years. The appearance lasted only a few minutes, but it won Foy a second Primetime Emmy, this time for Outstanding Guest Actress in a Drama Series at the 2021 ceremony: a second Emmy for a role she had handed over two years earlier.

She came back again in the premiere of the fifth series in 2022, and then, in the final episode of the sixth and last series in 2023, all three Queens appeared together. Foy, Colman and Imelda Staunton shared the screen. The Crown had asked viewers to accept three Queens, and by the end, it was hard to imagine the story any other way.

What the handover says about British acting

There is a reason the Foy to Colman handover is still discussed years later. It showed that recasting, often treated as a problem to be managed, can be an artistic choice in its own right. The series did not hide the change or apologise for it; it built the show around the idea that people change, institutions endure, and the same life looks different at 25, at 45 and at 65. Foy and Colman made that idea believable.

In the end, the pairing works because the two performances complete each other. Foy gives us the Queen becoming, Colman gives us the Queen enduring, and together they cover a life in a way no single performance could. That is why audiences still argue about which of them was better, the role needed them both. The Crown had one Queen, and it took two remarkable actresses to play her.

Back To Top