In December 2019, two of the finest young actors of their generation met in the same film. Greta Gerwig’s Little Women cast Saoirse Ronan as Jo March, the headstrong writer at the centre of Alcott’s novel, and Florence Pugh as Amy March, the youngest sister Jo spends much of the story fighting with. Both were nominated for Academy Awards, Ronan for best actress and Pugh for best supporting, and the film earned six nominations in all. Yet they had arrived there by opposite routes: one famous since thirteen, the other a virtual unknown three years earlier.
The child star who was already a veteran
Saoirse Una Ronan was born on 12 April 1994 in the Bronx, New York City, the only child of Irish parents Monica and Paul Ronan, both from Dublin. Her father was an actor, and the family moved back to Dublin when she was three. She debuted as a child on the Irish series The Clinic in 2003, and on film four years later in I Could Never Be Your Woman (2007).
Her breakthrough arrived the same year. In Atonement, Joe Wright’s adaptation of Ian McEwan’s novel, the thirteen-year-old Ronan played Briony Tallis, the girl whose lie destroys two lives. It earned her an Academy Award nomination for best supporting actress at thirteen, making her the seventh-youngest nominee in that category. She was still a child, already treated as one of the industry’s serious actors.
What followed was a career built on careful choices: The Lovely Bones in 2009, Hanna in 2011, and Wes Anderson’s The Grand Budapest Hotel in 2014. Then came the leading roles that made her one of the most acclaimed actors of her generation. Brooklyn in 2015 brought her a first best actress Oscar nomination, as an Irish immigrant torn between two countries. Lady Bird in 2017 brought her a second, and a Golden Globe for best actress at the January 2018 ceremony. Mary Queen of Scots followed in 2018, Ronan as the Scottish queen opposite Margot Robbie’s Elizabeth I.
By the time Gerwig cast her as Jo March, Ronan had three Academy Award nominations, seven BAFTA nominations, and a place on the Forbes 30 Under 30 list from 2016. In 2020, the New York Times ranked her tenth among the greatest actors of the twenty-first century, when she was twenty-six.
The late bloomer with the husky voice
Florence Rose Pugh was born on 3 January 1996 in Oxford, England, the daughter of dancer Deborah Pugh and restaurateur Clinton Pugh. When she was three, the family moved to Spain because of tracheomalacia, a condition in which the trachea narrows and makes breathing difficult. The warmer climate was meant to help her health. It stayed with her, but left her with an unexpected gift: the distinctive husky voice that became her trademark.
Unlike Ronan, Pugh did not grow up in front of the cameras. Her professional debut did not come until she was seventeen, in the mystery film The Falling in 2014. Her breakthrough came two years later in Lady Macbeth, a dark nineteenth-century drama in which she played Katherine, a young wife trapped in an unhappy marriage who escapes through an affair and murder. The performance drew rave reviews and won her the British Independent Film Award for best actress.
In 2018 she starred in the BBC miniseries The Little Drummer Girl, John le Carré’s spy story directed by Park Chan-wook, as a young actress recruited into espionage. It announced an actor ready for the biggest stages. Within a year, she was on them.
The year that made Pugh a star
If Ronan’s career had been a slow, steady climb, Pugh’s took off like a rocket in 2019. She began the year with Fighting with My Family, as the real-life wrestler Paige in a comedy about a working-class English family obsessed with wrestling. Then came Midsommar, Ari Aster’s folk horror film, in which she played Dani, a grieving graduate student who travels to rural Sweden for a festival that turns into a nightmare. Her raw performance carried almost every scene.
And then came Little Women. Gerwig’s adaptation gave Amy March, often the least loved sister, a sharper and more sympathetic portrait than she had ever received on screen. Pugh played her as vain, ambitious, funny and, underneath it all, fiercely loyal. The performance earned her nominations for best supporting actress at both the Academy Awards and the BAFTAs, her first at either ceremony. Three films in one year, three completely different characters, and by the end of 2019 Pugh had gone from promising newcomer to one of the most in-demand actors alive. She was twenty-three.
Little Women and the sisters at its centre
The film was a triumph. Written and directed by Gerwig, it starred Ronan and Pugh with Emma Watson as Meg, Eliza Scanlen as Beth, Timothée Chalamet as Laurie, and Laura Dern as Marmee. It was a critical and commercial success, earning six Academy Award nominations, including Pugh’s for best supporting actress and Ronan’s for best actress, her fourth overall.
The heart of the film is the relationship between Jo and Amy. Jo is the sister who wants to write and will not be tamed; Amy is the sister who wants to be loved and will not apologise for it. They fight over a manuscript Jo burns, a boy they both love, and what a woman’s life is allowed to be. Ronan plays Jo with restless energy, all sharp elbows and scribbled pages. Pugh plays Amy with a confidence that grows as the film goes on, from a spoiled twelve-year-old to a woman who knows exactly what she wants.
The casting has a neat symmetry. Ronan had played this story before: the young woman leaving home to make her own life, as in Brooklyn and Lady Bird. Pugh was playing a character audiences had been trained to dislike, and making her impossible to dismiss. Together they turned a sisterly rivalry into the film’s emotional spine, and both were recognised for it.
Two different routes to the same place
Side by side, the contrast is striking. Ronan was a prodigy, nominated for an Oscar before she was a teenager, and spent the next decade proving the early promise was real. Pugh was a late starter, unknown until her early twenties, and spent three years proving her breakthrough was not a fluke. One built her reputation slowly, film by film; the other arrived almost all at once.
Yet they share more than the difference suggests. Both are known for choosing difficult material over easy fame, and for total commitment. Both have also been frank about the parts they did not get. Ronan has spoken about auditioning for Luna Lovegood in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix as a child, losing the part to Evanna Lynch because she was too young. She has said the rejection stayed with her for years, even after four Oscar nominations.
The numbers tell part of the story. Ronan has four Academy Award nominations, seven BAFTA nominations, a Golden Globe, and a place on the New York Times list of the greatest actors of the century. Pugh has one Oscar nomination so far, earned in the same film as Ronan’s fourth — though Ronan had been just thirteen at her first. Neither has won an Oscar yet, which only adds to the sense that both careers are still climbing.
What came next
Since Little Women, both have kept growing in different directions. Pugh joined the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Yelena Belova, adopted sister of Scarlett Johansson’s Black Widow, first in Black Widow in 2021 and then in Hawkeye later that year, returning in Thunderbolts in 2025. She played Jean Tatlock, psychiatrist and former lover of J. Robert Oppenheimer, in Christopher Nolan’s Oppenheimer in 2023, and Princess Irulan in Dune: Part Two in 2024. Later that year she starred opposite Andrew Garfield in We Live in Time, as a chef with terminal cancer.
Ronan, meanwhile, took a different kind of step forward. In 2024 she produced and starred in The Outrun, playing a woman returning to the Orkney Islands after years of addiction, a role that drew some of the strongest reviews of her career. It was her first credit as producer: an actor taking control of her own work. For another pairing of two very different British stars, read our piece on Gordon Ramsay and Jamie Oliver.
Little Women remains where their two careers crossed, at exactly the right moment. Ronan was the established star lending the film its centre of gravity; Pugh the rising talent giving it its surprise. One had spent a decade becoming one of the best actors alive; the other three years proving she belonged in the same conversation. On screen, as Jo and Amy, they argued, reconciled, and made each other better. Off screen, it did the same for both: it confirmed Ronan as the actor of her generation, and announced Pugh as the one who would follow her there.
